This is a pretty average number for a quarterback with incredible potential. Madden is a staple of the video game world, and yesterday, they released the ratings of all the rookie quarterbacks. So with Herbert and Tagovailoa nearly identical on short-to-intermediate throws and Tua being better down the field gives the Crimson Tide signal-caller an ever-so-slight advantage in the most vital aspect of playing the quarterback position.

Born and raised in Hawaii to Samoan parents, he attended Saint Louis School in Honolulu. CBS Sports is a registered trademark of CBS Broadcasting Inc. Commissioner.com is a registered trademark of CBS Interactive Inc. site: media | arena: nfl | pageType: stories | The best quarterbacks on earth thrive here. But it's a prerequisite to being an advanced passer, and is essentially a must at the NFL level. 6-keys: media/spln/nfl/draft/free/stories, at Below are the five categories on which I grade quarterbacks. 2021 NFL Draft Targets Giants Fans Should Watch On 10/3, 2021 NFL Draft: 5 Most Likely No. This category features a landslide. It's self-explanatory. Much of it has to do with poor footwork. Herbert's long strides and ankle flexibility allow him to move the chains somewhat easily in third-down situations when he's forced out of the pocket. His front foot tends to stride too far outside his intended target, and because he's not a large quarterback who can create tons of momentum with his upper body alone, those throws lack velocity. Has success challenging all levels of the field with sound accuracy. Did Washington Err By Not Drafting QB Over Chase Young? Pocket drifting and pocket presence together formulate pocket management, and Tom Brady is the ultimate master of it. Rarely (if ever) is the ball dying as it arrives to its target. Pocket drifting is the ability to subtly drift away from pressure within the confines of the pocket. He isn’t the tallest quarterback but the density of his frame is ideal for his style of play. This is another category in which the two top quarterback prospects are very close and clearly ahead of the pack in their draft class. EA Sports’ Madden Franchise has been pumping out game after game for years and the newest iteration, Madden 21, is set to come out in August. Takes full advantage of the incredible speed at his disposal with the Bama WRs and works the football down the field with excellent success. Covering the impact of coronavirus on the sports world. It's bad. Tagovailoa's downfield accuracy was a clear step ahead of Herbert last season, although the former threw to wide open receivers more frequently on vertical routes. Nope. He was given an 81-speed rating, which is a bit lower than expected, especially since Burrow was given an 83. PROS: Love how controlled he is among chaos and somehow finds ways to stay in rhythm. 1 Overall Pick? Tua Tagovailoa or Justin Herbert? (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images). He helped to lead the Crimson Tide to back-to-back National Championship Game appearances during … Another layer to this is the fact that short-area accuracy and deep-ball accuracy weren't created equal in terms of importance. It's the long throws across the field, toward the sideline, or when, at the intermediate level, he attempts to fit the ball through a tight window when his weaker arm appears. This year is no different and if there is one rookie who Miami fans are excited to see it’s their new franchise quarterback. INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 27: Quarterback Tua Tagovailoa of Alabama looks on during the NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 27, 2020 in Indianapolis, Indiana. Each year, fans eagerly await the games reveal of their incoming rookie class. His throwing accuracy numbers for the game are at an 86 for short accuracy, 81 for medium accuracy, and 80 for deep accuracy, which is a solid number that is a good translation of his game from college. CONS: Delivery features a slight hitch.

Lawrence vs Tagovailoa: What If Texans Gift Dolphins No. Tagovailoa and Herbert are already full-field readers. His quick processing skills, trigger, accuracy and ability to remain comfortable under duress are exceptional qualities that give him a great chance to succeed at the next level. Tagovailoa has impressed in every facet as a quarterback, from his decision making, to his accuracy, to his downfield throwing, which is one of the more … Tagovailoa has slightly better ball placement -- think hitting a receiver perfectly in stride -- on those throws.

This most important category is significantly closer than those numbers indicate.

This category represents the least-important element of playing the quarterback position. Herbert is a more towering and athletically imposing athlete than Tagovailoa. He has no problem ripping in-breaking routes across the middle, and he routinely drives the football across the field on lengthy throws toward the sideline. The ball jumps out of his hand. They are listed in order of importance, with the most important category at the top. But in the modern NFL, a quarterback's legs can be a useful bonus for offensive coordinators and annoying for defenders.

In July, I pinpointed deep-ball accuracy as flaws both need to fix this season. Following that, he attended the University of Alabama to play college football. Herbert's on-target rate on those deep balls was 55.4% (77th place). They've showcased the wherewithal to slide or step out of bounds before the big hit arrives. Obviously, Madden ratings are no clear indicator of how a player will perform in any given season, but for die-hard players, these numbers matter as they try and bring glory to their favorite franchises. NFL says no to jersey swaps but tackling is still allowed in 2020, NFL says no fans will attend training camp sessions this year, I don’t think he is that far behind Burrow, Miami Dolphins 2020 training camp preview: Chandler Cox, Jerry Jeudy Taken by Jaguars in B/R User 2020 NFL Mock Draft, Miami Dolphins fringe receivers chances of making the 2020 roster, Miami Dolphins fans should wait to buy single game tickets. Occasionally passes toward the sideline are sinking as they arrive. Tagovailoa gets the edge here because he's faster through those reads and less likely to lock onto the first target in his progression when its simply not open. Powered by Minute Media © 2020 All Rights Reserved. You've watched all the tape, you know the stats. Herbert has better speed, and is thereby more efficient when getting North-South.

I repeatedly refer to Herbert's arm as "live." When Should Dolphins Name Tua Tagovailoa Their Starter? Does a terrific job navigating the pocket, keeping his eyes down the field and finding his outlets under duress. Arm strength is good enough but he doesn’t have a cannon. 1 Overall Picks, 5 ACC Sleepers To Keep An Eye On This Season. Some team -- likely the club with the No. Effectively mixes up his fastball and changeup based on the type of throw required for the situation. Per SIS, the Alabama star was on target on 64.8% of his throws (23rd place) and made 20 or more yards downfield. They've put a variety of high-level throws on film after stepping up or moving laterally away from an oncoming defender inside the pocket.

© 2004-2020 CBS Interactive. That is the 2020 NFL Draft's most preeminent question, and this college football season will provide the most important evidence needed to answer it. He also got an 84 on his play-action rating, which is something that is exciting for Madden players since play action can usually open up the field of play, similarly to what it does in the real game. Build your custom FanSided Daily email newsletter with news and analysis on Miami Dolphins and all your favorite sports teams, TV shows, and more. That's easy, right? At times, I'll refer to this as pocket presence, I just think pocket patience explains what I'm detailing a little better. According to Sports Info Solutions, in the 0-to-19-yard range, Tagovailoa had an "on-target percentage" of 79.3%. By now, you, the intelligent football fan, know a quarterback's accuracy shouldn't strictly be measured by completion percentage. Impeccable character and leadership qualities. Therefore, a full-field reader gives an offensive coordinator a much more expansive playbook and is drastically more difficult for a secondary to defend.